What Jimmy Buffett’s Estate Battle Teaches Us About Trust Planning

jimmy-buffet-margaritaville

Jimmy Buffett was known for living the laid-back, beach-bum lifestyle, but the battle over his $275 million estate is anything but relaxing. His widow, Jane Buffett, is now locked in a legal dispute with co-trustee Richard Mozenter, raising big questions about trust management, fiduciary duty, and how even well-planned estates can go off course.

Buffett did a lot right: he created a marital trust, updated his estate plan over the years, and ensured his wife and children were financially supported. But now, Jane is accusing Mozenter of being uncooperative, withholding financial information, and charging excessive fees—while Mozenter claims Jane has interfered with his role as trustee. The result? A bitter, public, and expensive court battle.

What Went Wrong?

Two key decisions seem to have opened the door to conflict:

  1. Appointing a Co-Trustee Without Clear Communication: Buffett appointed Mozenter—his longtime business manager—as co-trustee alongside his wife. This created tension between personal and professional roles, especially after Buffett’s passing.
  2. No Built-In Removal Mechanism: Jane had no simple legal route to remove Mozenter, even if their relationship turned adversarial. That power could have been included in the trust language.

How to Avoid a Buffett-Sized Breakdown

  • Choose Trustees Carefully: Friends or advisors may not always work well with your loved ones. Professional trustees often bring objectivity and structure.
  • Communicate Your Plan: Let beneficiaries and co-trustees know what to expect. Surprises are a fast track to litigation.
  • Include Flexibility: Build in removal or mediation clauses so conflicts can be resolved without court.
  • Keep Business & Family Separate: If possible, don’t mix emotional and financial relationships unless everyone understands the expectations.

Planning That Protects

Buffett had great intentions—but even the best documents can cause damage when real people, emotions, and millions of dollars are involved.

If you want your legacy to be protected, and not argued over, it’s time to talk about life planning. We help families in Florida set up estate plans that work in real life, not just on paper.Book your consultation today at 904-329-7242 or visit markmosslaw.com to build a plan that protects the people you love, even when you’re not here to keep the peace.